| Year | Winner | Sponsor |
| 2023 | Ashley Keisterk | Rosemarie Johnson |
| Isabella Keh | Roland Keh | |
| Brendan Elliott | Jerome Elliott, Sr. | |
| Derek Caiazzo | Guy Caiazzo | |
| Claire Peiffer | Mary Pollina-Knab | |
| Carolyn Davis | Mary Pollina-Knab | |
| Charles Petro | Michael Petro | |
| 2022 | Ashley Keisterk | Rosemarie Johnson |
| Brendan Elliott | Jerome Elliott, Sr. | |
| Sophia Montcalmo | Anthony Montcalmo | |
| Isabella Keh | Roland Keh | |
| Madelin McLean | Dr. Paul R. Rao | |
| Ingrid Lenzenweger | Teresa Lenzenweger | |
| Ethan Zielinsky | Clera Zielinsky | |
| 2021 | Gabriella Lasek | Maria Teresi |
| Brendan Elliott | Jerome Elliott, Sr. | |
| Derek Caiazzo | Guy Caiazzo | |
| Marco Hague | Mary Margaret Hague | |
| Ashley R. Keister | Rosemarie Johnson | |
| Mia Lenzenweger | Teresa Lenzenweger | |
| 2020 | Isabella Keh | Roland Keh |
| Mia Lenzenweger | Teresa Lenzenweger | |
| Madelin McLean | Dr. Paul R. Rao | |
| Michaela Rusinko | John Rusinko | |
| 2019 | Anthony Apicella | Mary Apicella |
| Isabella Barbieri | Anthony Barbieri | |
| Jackson Landgraf | Kenneth O’Day | |
| Maria Laske | Maria Nicole Teresi | |
| 2018 | Isabella Barbieri | Anthony Barbieri |
| Jackson Landgraf | Kenneth O’Day | |
| Wyatt Laudicina | Charles Anthony Laudicina | |
| Gabriella McClean | Dr. Paul Rao | |
| 2017 | Anna Cuffari | |
| Victoria Tully | ||
| 2016 | Isabella Barbieri | Anthony Barbieri |
| Cullen Siepp | Pat Novak | |
| 2015 | Anna Berrettini | Leo & Grace Otterbien |
| Nicholas Butta | Victoria Butta | |
| Elizabeth Guidice | Barbara Goodman | |
| Brooke Lorber | Fred & Joan Petrella | |
| 2014 | Nicholas Butta | Victoria Butta |
| Alexander Culotta | Sam and Leah Culotta | |
| Ian Hughes | Celeste Hughes | |
| Justin Lorber | Fred and Joan Petrella | |
| 2013 | Nicholas Butta | Victoria Butta |
| Alexander Culotta | Sam and Leah Culotta | |
| Brooke Lorber | Fred & Joan Petrella | |
| Anthony Meek | Gisele Ferretto | |
| 2012 | Michael Butta | Victoria Butta |
| Nicholas Butta | Victoria Butta | |
| Brianna Collachi | Mary Jo Vondersmith | |
| Drew Myers | Delores Adler | |
| 2011 | Michael Butta | Victoria Butta |
| Charles Corasaniti | Susan Corasaniti | |
| Sal Corasaniti | Susan Corasaniti | |
| Drew Myers | Delores Adler | |
| 2010 | Jillian Augustyniak | Mel and Rose Augustyniak |
| Michael Butta | Victoria Butta | |
| Maria Ferrante | Silvana Ferrante | |
| Jamie Restivo | Valerie Restivo | |
| 2009 | Katie Ann Augustyniak | Mel and Rose Augustyniak |
| Alexandra Elliott | Angela Elliott | |
| Jamie Restivo | Valerie Restivo | |
| 2008 | Katie Ann Augustyniak | Mel and Rose Augustyniak |
| Alexandra Elliott | Angela Elliott | |
| Maria Ferrante | Silvana Ferrante | |
| Jamie Restivo | Valerie Restivo | |
| 2007 | Alexandra Elliott | Angela Elliott |
| Maria Ferrante | Silvana Ferrante | |
| Sarah Kidd | Lucy Ferri | |
| C.Patrick Passaro | Frand Passaro | |
| 2006 | Katie Ann Augustyniak | Mel and Rose Augustyniak |
| Maria Ferrante | Silvana Ferrante | |
| C.Patrick Passaro | Frand Passaro | |
| 2005 | Katie Ann Augustyniak | Mel and Rose Augustyniak |
| Maria Ferrante | Silvana Ferrante | |
| 2004 | Jennifer Difolco | Debra Difolco |
| Max Pompa | Lucy Pompa | |
| 2003 | Jennifer DiFolco | Debra Difolco |
| Bianca Posterli | Robert and Fernando Posterli | |
| 2002 | Katelynn Petrella | Joseph Petrella |
| Bianca Posterli | Robert and Fernando Posterli | |
| 2001 | Stephanie Anderson | John and Mary Butta |
| Michelle Stanley | Clair and Tony Sallese | |
| 2000 | John J. D’Adamo | Ann D’Adamo |
| Danielle Lombardi | ||
| 1999 | Cathan Daughtery | Caroline Chaparelli Gramil |
| Danielle Lombardi |